These days, it seems like everyone is testing the capabilities of large language models (LLMs). From answering trivia to business valuation, these AI tools have sparked excitement and curiosity about what they can really do. 

But when the stakes are high, like when determining the value of your business, you don’t want to risk making pivotal decisions based on hallucinated or inaccurate information.

In this guide, we’ll discuss how three popular tools—ChatGPT, Claude, and Quiet Light—stack up when it comes to business valuation.

Related Article: Top AI Tools to Help You Scale Your Online Business

What Is a Business Valuation Tool?

A business valuation tool helps you calculate your business’s worth based on various financial metrics, market conditions, and other relevant factors. 

Different valuation methods, such as the seller’s discretionary earnings (SDE) method, discounted cash-flow (DCF) analysis, and the market capitalization business valuation method, offer different perspectives on a business’s value. 

While basic online calculators can provide a quick snapshot of your business’s value, they often lack depth and nuance. These tools can be useful for getting a particular perspective, but they don’t account for all the unique aspects of your business that might impact the value.

For a more comprehensive and reliable valuation, it’s best to undergo an in-depth review with a professional who can analyze all quantitative and qualitative factors. 

“While basic online calculators can provide a quick snapshot of your business’s value using some of these methods, they often lack the depth and nuance needed for a truly accurate valuation.”

Pros and Cons of ChatGPT for Business Valuation

Pros

• Quick and free: If you use the basic version, ChatGPT can provide a general estimate quickly without cost. 
• Introductory learning: If you’re new to business valuations, ChatGPT can help you understand the basics and explore the process.
• Practice tool: ChatGPT offers a fast and easy way to practice and explore various valuation scenarios. 
• Data security: The paid version of ChatGPT does not train models on your data, offering more privacy. 
• Document handling: ChatGPT can view PDFs and visit website links for additional context. 

“If you’re new to business valuations, ChatGPT can help you understand the basics and explore the process.”

Cons

• Input-dependent quality: The valuation’s quality depends heavily on the prompts and inputs you provide. 
• Information handling limitations: ChatGPT often struggles with large volumes of complex information and can “hallucinate” or provide inaccurate results. 
• Lack of precision: ChatGPT’s estimates are unlikely to be precise enough for making serious business decisions. 
• Data security: The free version uses your data to train its models, which can be risky for confidential business information. 
• Insufficient for in-depth valuations: It lacks the ability to perform the comprehensive assessments needed for a reliable business valuation. 

“ChatGPT’s estimates are unlikely to be precise enough for making serious business decisions.”

Pros and Cons of Claude for Business Valuation

Pros

• Extensive text handling: Claude can read up to 75,000 words at a time, handling more information in one go. 
• Ethics focus: Claud was developed with a strong focus on ethics by ex-OpenAI employees. 
• Document handling: Claude can view PDFs and summarize findings. 
• Better free version: Claude’s free version is generally considered superior to ChatGPT’s free version. 

“Claude’s free version is generally considered superior to ChatGPT’s free version.”

Cons

• Limited features: Claude lacks a number of capabilities such as data analysis, voice chat, web browsing, and image creation. 
• No access to external information: Claude can only use the information provided in the prompt and cannot access the internet for market trends or current data.

“Claude can only use the information provided in the prompt and cannot access the internet for market trends or current data.”

Pros and Cons of Quiet Light for Business Valuation

Pros

• In-depth analysis: Quiet Light offers a thorough valuation considering both quantitative and qualitative data. 
• Tailored insights: With Quiet Light, you can get insights into strengths and areas for improvement.
• Free service: The valuation service is offered at no cost, providing high value without a financial commitment.
• No learning curve: Unlike AI tools, Quiet Light’s valuation process does not require you to learn how to prompt or interact with the system.

“Quiet Light offers a thorough valuation considering both quantitative and qualitative data.”

Cons

• You have to work with real humans: You’ll have to deal with actual people, which means no typing to a robot and getting instant (but surface-level) responses. But hey: at least these humans are experts in business valuation and care about your business!

What’s the Verdict?

While LLMs like ChatGPT and Claude have their place, especially for exploring and familiarizing yourself with the business valuation process, they come with limitations. These tools can be useful for preliminary research or playing around with different valuation scenarios. Still, they should not be relied upon for making critical business decisions due to the potential for inaccuracy and data security concerns. 

If you’re looking for a super rough estimate, ChatGPT or Claude might help—but you’ll have to consider accuracy and privacy of your data.

If you need a reliable valuation that considers all aspects of your business, working with a professional service like Quiet Light is the best approach. Quiet Light goes beyond mere calculations, providing strategic insights and comprehensive analysis that can guide your decisions effectively. 

When it comes to selling your business, there’s no wrong reason, but there is a right time and way. Quiet Light’s Advisors bring real-life experience and relentless honesty to help you understand your business’s true value and market readiness. Whether you’re ready to sell now or planning for the future, Quiet Light is here to ensure you make the most of your business sale. 

Contact us for a free, no-strings-attached valuation.